top of page
Home: Welcome
514-4 Middle Country Road
Middle Island, NY 11953


Appointment Only

Yes! We have decided to go appointment only and it's a great thing!  It allows me to have a broader range of availability, while still being able to be active in the equine community!  You will see me out and about much more doing pop-up events, saddle trials, or even talking insurance with The Rustic Brokerage! As a horse girl, when I'm not with you at the store, you will find me at the barn! Call to book or click the link below!
Image by Hunter Folsom


Questions, comments or special requests? Get in touch today, we’re happy to help!

We also try to price match if possible!

Don't see an item? Ask me if I carry it!

Thanks for submitting!


"Give a horse what he needs and he will give you his heart in return"

My name is Kristi and I was born and raised on Long Island with a passion for the local equine industry and all things farmhouse.  I am a resident of Middle Island, NY and have created my own little farmstead along with my husband, two young boys, 3 dogs and my OTTB. 

Rustic Home & Tack started as an online shop for Farmhouse decor and English and Western Tack in 2020 during the shutdown. I opened the business in addition to working as an Insurance Agent from home while my kids also learned from home. Over the past two years I have really grown to learn what the community needs from my shop and I am excited to bring it to you with a physical location!

We needed a shop for the lovers of the simpler, ranch style living, the backyard rider, the trail rider, the new rider and the western rider. 

I believe my store is headed in the right direction to fill this void we have here with plenty of room to learn and grow from you!

Please come visit me at my new location and please remember to sign up for loyalty rewards!

bottom of page